Should Liberal Democracy Respect Group Rights that Discriminate against Women and Apostates?
Copyright (c) 2023 Cohen-Almagor Raphael
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The paper examines the limits of state interference in proscribing cultural norms by considering gender discrimination, right of people to leave their community free of penalties, denying women appropriate education, and forced or arranged marriages for girls and young women. The discussion opens by reflecting on the discriminatory practices of the Pueblo tribes against their women and analysing an American court case, Santa Clara v. Martinez. It is argued that the severity of rights violations within the minority group, the insufficient dispute-resolution-mechanisms, and the inability of individuals to leave the community if they so desire without penalty justify state intervention to uphold the dissenters’ basic rights. Next, a Canadian case, Hofer v. Hofer, illustrates the problematics of denying reasonable exit right to members who may wish to leave their community. Subsequently, the discussion turns to the issue of arranged and forced marriages of girls and young women. While the latter is coercive the former is not. While forced marriages should be denounced as unjust, arranged marriages can be accepted. Finally, the paper considers denying education to women, arguing that such a denial is unjust and discriminatory.
How to Cite
Altman, Y. (2018, October 21). Where did the assets of Yemenite immigrants disappear. Israel Hayom (Israeli daily, Hebrew).
Archives of the State of Israel, G5543/3631, file 607 (II). See also G5543/3631, file 607 (III).
Bächtiger, A, Dryzek, J. S., Mansbridge, J. & Warren, M. (Eds.) (2018). The Oxford Handbook of Deliberative Democracy. Oxford University Press. Online: https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198747369.001.0001
Barry, B. (2001). Culture and Equality. Harvard University Press.
Benhabib, S. (2002). The Claims of Culture: Equality and Diversity in the Global Era. Princeton University Press.
Bird, G. (Ed.) (2006). A Companion to Kant. Blackwell.
Britannica (s. a.). Ancestral Pueblo culture. Online: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Ancestral-Pueblo-culture
Brown, R. A. (1930). The Indian Problem and the Law. Yale Law Journal, 39(3), 307–331. Online: https://doi.org/10.2307/789897
Burton, N. (2018, January 4). The Pros and Cons of Polygamy. Psychology Today. Online: https://bit.ly/45rRpMn
Canada (AG) v. Lavell  S.C.R. 1349.
Christofferson, C. (1991). Tribal Courts’ Failure to Protect Native American Women: A Reevaluation of the Indian Civil Rights Act. Yale Law Journal, 101(1), 169–185. Online: https://doi.org/10.2307/796937
Cohen-Almagor, R. (1994). The Boundaries of Liberty and Tolerance: The Struggle Against Kahanism in Israel. The University Press of Florida.
Cohen-Almagor, R. (1995). Cultural Pluralism and the Israeli Nation-Building Ideology. International Journal of Middle East Studies, 27(4), 461–484. Online: https://www.jstor.org/stable/176365
Cohen-Almagor, R. (Ed.) (2005). Israeli Democracy at the Crossroads. Routledge.
Cohen-Almagor, R. (2006a). The Scope of Tolerance: Studies on the Costs of Free Expression and Freedom of the Press. Routledge.
Cohen-Almagor, R. (2006b). On Compromise and Coercion. Ratio Juris, 19(4), 434–455. Online: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9337.2006.00338.x
Cohen-Almagor, R. (2018). Discrimination against Jewish Women in Halacha (Jewish Law) and in Israel. British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 45(2), 290–310. Online: https://doi.org/10.1080/13530194.2016.1258543
Cohen-Almagor, R. (2021a). Just, Reasonable Multiculturalism: Liberalism, Culture and Coercion. Cambridge University Press. Online: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108567213
Cohen-Almagor, R. (2021b). Coercion. Open Journal of Philosophy, 11(3), 386–409. Online: https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=111463
Cohen-Almagor, R. (2022). The Republic, Secularism and Security: France versus the Burqa and the Niqab. Springer. Online: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-94669-2
Cohen-Almagor, R. & Maroshek-Klarman, U. (2023). Gender Discrimination in Israel. In A. Tyc, Z. Góral, & J. Carby-Hall (Eds.), Discrimination and Employment Law: International Legal Perspectives (pp. 248–276). Routledge.
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1979). Online: https://www.ohchr.org/EN/ProfessionalInterest/Pages/CEDAW.aspx
Convention on the Rights of the Child, Adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by General Assembly resolution 44/25 of 20 November 1989, entry into force 2 September 1990. Online: http://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/crc.aspx
Declaration on the Elimination of all Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief (1981). Online: https://www.ohchr.org/EN/ProfessionalInterest/Pages/ReligionOrBelief.aspx
Deveaux, M. (2009). Gender and Justice in Multicultural Liberal States. Oxford University Press.
Dryzek, J. S. (2002). Deliberative Democracy and Beyond. Oxford University Press.
Dryzek, J. S. (2012). Foundations and Frontiers of Deliberative Governance. Oxford University Press.
Eisenberg, A. (2007). Reasoning about the Identity of Aboriginal People. In S. Tierney (Ed.), Accommodating Cultural Diversity (pp. 79–97). Ashgate.
Eisenberg, A. & Spinner-Halev, J. (Eds.) (2009). Minorities within Minorities: Equality, Diversity and Rights. Cambridge University Press. Online: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511490224
Elbedour, S., Onwuegbuzie, A. J., Cardidine, C. & Abu-Saad, H. (2002). The Effect of Polygamous Marital Structure on Behavioral, Emotional, and Academic Adjustment in Children: A Comprehensive Review of the Literature. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 5, 255–271. Online: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1020925123016
Fontaine, T. (2016, May 10). Canada officially adopts UN declaration on rights of Indigenous Peoples. CBC. Online: https://bit.ly/43jYaOE
Frantzman, S. J. (2016, December 29). The tragedy and shame of 1950s Israel’s treatment of Yemenite children. The Jerusalem Post. Online: https://bit.ly/42XKYze
Gertel, G. (2019, September 12). Women are more educated than men, but earn less than them. Sicha Mekomit. Online: https://bit.ly/3BMhKHB
Gewirth, A. (1983). The Rationality of Reasonableness. Synthese, 57(2), 225–247. Online: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01064003
Global Gender Gap Report 2020, World Economic Forum. Online http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_GGGR_2020.pdf
Goldberg, M. (2013, July 1). Moral problems in Halacha: Women. Truetorah – A response to Naftali Zeligman’s “Letter to my Rabbi”. Online: https://bit.ly/425Dvwt
Habermas, J. (1990). Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action. MIT Press.
Habermas, J. (1996). Between Facts and Norms. Polity.
Halperin-Kaddari, R. (2004). Women in Israel: A State of Their Own. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Halperin-Kaddari, R. & Yadgar, Y. (2010). Between Universal Feminism and Particular Nationalism: Politics, Religion and Gender (In)equality in Israel. Third World Quarterly, 31(6), 905–920. Online: https://www.jstor.org/stable/27896588
Hassouneh-Phillips, D. (2001). Polygamy and Wife Abuse: A Qualitative Study of Muslim Women in America. Health Care for Women International, 22(8), 735–748. Online: https://doi.org/10.1080/073993301753339951
Heath, M. (2023). Forbidden Intimacies: Polygamies at the Limits of Western Tolerance. Stanford University Press.
Hofer et al. v. Hofer et al. (1970) S.C.R. 958.
House of Commons (2018, November 20). Polygamy.
Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 (ICRA), 25 U.S.C.§§ 1301–1304 (ICRA). Online: https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/Indian-Civil-Rights-Act-of-1968.pdf
International Convention for Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1967). Online: http://www.ipu.org/PDF/publications/cedaw_en.pdf
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966). Online: https://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/ccpr.aspx
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966). Online: https://www.ohchr.org/EN/Professionalinterest/Pages/CESCR.aspx
Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2013, December 31). Ensuring equal rights for women in Israel. Online: https://bit.ly/3OG7B6G
Janzen, W. (1990). Limits of Liberty: The Experiences of Mennonite, Hutterite, and Doukhobour Communities in Canada. University of Toronto Press.
Jessup Newton, N. (1984). Federal Power over Indians: Its sources, scope and limitations. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 132(2), 195–288.
Johnson v. M’Intosh, 21 U.S. (8 Wheat.) 543 (1823).
Judaism 101 (s. a.). The Role of Women. Online: http://www.jewfaq.org/women.htm
Kant, I. (1969). Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals. Bobbs-Merrill Educational Publishers.
Katz, Y. & Lehr, J. (2012). The Hutterites in Canada and the United States. University of Regina Press.
Kedar, A., Amara, A. & Yiftachel, O. (2018). Emptied Lands: A Legal Geography of Bedouin Rights in the Negev. Stanford University Press.
Kukathas, C. (1997). Cultural Toleration. Nomos, 39, 69–104. Online: https://www.jstor.org/stable/24219972
Kukathas, C. (2003). The Liberal Archipelago: A Theory of Diversity and Freedom. Oxford University Press.
Kymlicka, W. (1989). Liberalism, Community, and Culture. Clarendon Press.
Kymlicka, W. (1997). Do We Need a Liberal Theory of Minority Rights?: Reply to Carens, Young, Parekh and Forst. Constellations, 4(1), 72–87. Online: https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8675.00038
Kymlicka, W. (2000). Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority. Oxford University Press.
Kymlicka, W. & Cohen-Almagor, R. (2000). Ethnocultural Minorities in Liberal Democracies. In M. Baghramian & A. Ingram (Eds.), Pluralism: The Philosophy and Politics of Diversity (pp. 228–250). Routledge.
Malach, G. & Kahaner, L. (2018). Yearbook of Haredi Society in Israel 2018. The Israel Democracy Institute.
Malhi, A. & Abramovsky, M. (2015). Integration of Family and Work among Ultra-Orthodox Women. Ministry of Economy.
Margalit-Stern, B.-S. (2006). Model Friendship. Kathedra, 118, 115–144.
Marriage Age Law, 5710-1950.
McCrudden, C. (Ed.) (2014). Understanding Human Dignity. Oxford University Press – British Academy.
Meacham, T. (2009). Legal-Religious Status of the Jewish Female. Jewish Women Encyclopedia. Online: http://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/legal-religious-status-of-jewish-female
Menelson-Maoz, A. (2014). Multiculturalism in Israel. Purdue University Press.
Mill, J.S. (1948). Utilitarianism, Liberty, and Representative Government. J. M. Dent.
Noble, B. (2015, June 15). First five countries to recognise gay marriage. Newsmax. Online: https://bit.ly/41V5SNT
O’Flynn, I. (2021). Deliberative Democracy. Polity.
Okin, S. M. (1999). Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women? In J. Cohen, M. Howard & M. C. Nussbaum (Eds.), Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women? (pp. 9–24). Princeton University Press.
Popper, K. R. (1962). The Open Society and Its Enemies. Vol. 1. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Rawls, J. (1971). A Theory of Justice. Oxford University Press.
Rawls, J. (1988). The Priority of Right and Ideas of the Good. Philosophy & Public Affairs, 17(4), 251–276. Online: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2265400
Rawls, J. (1993). Political Liberalism. Columbia University Press.
Report of The Committee for the Advancement and Representation of Women in Institutions of High Education (2015). “Women in Higher Education Institutions in Israel.”
Resnik, J. (1989). Dependent Sovereigns: Indian Tribes, States, and the Federal Courts. University of Chicago Law Review, 56(2), 671–759. Online: https://doi.org/10.2307/1599849
Santa Clara Pueblo v. Martinez 436 US 49 (1978).
Schneiderman, D. (1998). Human Rights, Fundamental Differences? Multiple Charters in a New Partnership. In G. Laforest & R. Gibbins (Eds.), Beyond the Impasse: Toward Reconciliation (pp. 147–185). Institute for Research in Public Policy.
Shachar, A. (2001). Multicultural Jurisdictions: Cultural Differences and Women’s Rights. Cambridge University Press. Online: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511490330
Shalev, C. (2005). Health Rights. In R. Cohen-Almagor (Ed.), Israeli Democracy at the Crossroads (pp. 65–77). Routledge.
Song, S. (2007). Justice, Gender, and the Politics of Multiculturalism. Cambridge University Press. Online: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511490354
Spinner-Halev, J. (2000). Surviving Diversity: Religion and Democratic Citizenship. Johns Hopkins University Press.
Spinner-Halev, J. (2001). Feminism, Multiculturalism, Oppression, and the State. Ethics, 112(1), 84–113. Online: https://doi.org/10.1086/322741
Tsosie, R. (2011). Reconceptualizing Tribal Rights: Can self-determination be actualized within the U.S. constitutional structure? Lewis & Clark Law Review, 15(4), 923–950.
Uni, A. (2019, December 17). Israel slips 18 places in Gender Gap Index. Globes. Online: https://bit.ly/3pYPS01
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples 61/295 (September 13, 2007).
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948). Online: http://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/
U.S. Department of State (2011). Announcement of U.S. Support for the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, 1–2 (January 12). Online: https://2009-2017.state.gov/s/srgia/154553.htm
Valencia-Weber, G. (2004). Santa Clara Pueblo V. Martinez: Twenty-Five Years of Disparate Cultural Visions an Essay Introducing the Case for Re-Argument Before the American Indian Nations Supreme Court. Kansas Journal of Law & Pubic Policy, 14(1), 49–66. Online: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2265961
Vitikainen, A. (2015). The Limits of Liberal Multiculturalism: Towards an Individuated Approach to Cultural Diversity. Palgrave. Online: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137404626
Walker, G. (2000). The Idea of Non-liberal Constitutionalism. In I. Shapiro & W. Kymlicka (Eds.), Ethnicity and Group Rights (pp. 154–184). New York University Press.
Wilkins, D. E. (1994). Johnson v. M’Intosh Revisited: Through the Eyes of Mitchel v. United States. American Indian Law Review, 19(1), 159–181.
Wilkinson, C. (2006). Blood Struggle: The Rise of Modern Indian Nations. W. W. Norton.
Williams Jr. R. (1995). Sovereignty, Racism, Human Rights: Indian Self-Determination and the Postmodern World Legal System. Review of Constitutional Studies, 2, 146–202.
Zaken, D. (2019, December 24). Thanks to women: the standard of living of ultra-Orthodox society is steadily rising. Globes.