Changes in the Right to Property from the Aspect of Intellectual History

  • Jenő Szmodis
doi: 10.32566/AH.2026.1.2

Abstract

From antiquity to the Middle Ages, the right to property was a legal institution tied to status, political roles, and hierarchical relationships, rather than an abstract individual right. Its function was inextricably linked to the order of community, power, and inheritance. During the era of absolutism, thinking regarding property reached a turning point. Modern natural law perspectives emerged (Bodin, Grotius, Locke), while Hobbes emphasized its state-originated nature in a legal context. The 18th and 19th centuries were characterized by a search for balance between the constitutional protection of private property and restrictions in the public interest, where liberalism and codification acknowledged the social obligations of ownership. In the 20th century, property became an ideological issue: liberalism viewed it as a fundamental right, socialism and communism as an institution to be strictly limited or abolished, and fascist and Nazi ideologies as a specific political tool. 21st-century postmodern approaches often seek to transform property into a functional, access-based institution aligned with global goals, which leads to the relativization of individual autonomy and legal certainty.

Keywords:

history of property rights status-based property natural law state constitutional protection of property public-interest limitations ideological conceptions of property postmodernism individual autonomy legal certainty

References

AUKEN, Ida (2016): Welcome to 2030. I Own Nothing, Have No Privacy, and Life Has Never Been Better. Medium, 2016. november 12. Online: https://medium.com/world-economic-forum/welcome-to-2030-i-own-nothing-have-no-privacy-and-life-has-never-been-better-ee2eed62f710

Arisztotelész (1994): Politika. Ford. Szabó Miklós. Budapest: Gondolat.

BENTHAM, Jeremy (1977) [1789]: Bevezetés az erkölcsök és a törvényhozás alapelveibe. Ford. Fehér Ferenc. In MÁRKUS György (szerk.): Brit moralisták a XVIII. században. Budapest: Gondolat, 8–61.

BLOCH, Marc (2002): A feudális társadalom. Ford. Sujtó László. Budapest: Osiris.

BODIN, Jean (1987) [1576]: Az államról. Ford. Csűrös Klára, Máté Györgyi. Budapest: Gondolat.

BURKE, Edmund (1990) [1790]: Gondolatok a francia forradalomról. Ford. Kontler László. Budapest: Atlantisz.

Code civil, 1804.

DUBY, Georges (1962): L'Économie rurale et la vie des campagnes dans l'Occident médiéval. Paris: Aubier.

ENGELS, Friedrich (1954) [1845]: A munkásosztály helyzete Angliában. Ford. Bólyai Ernő. Budapest: Szikra.

EVANS, Richard J. (2015): A Harmadik Birodalom születése. Budapest: Park.

Gaius Institúciói (2014). Ford. Brósz Róbert. Budapest: Szent István Társulat.

GROTIUS, Hugo (1999) [1625]: A háború és béke jogáról. Ford. Haraszti György. Budapest: Pallas Stúdió.

Hammurabi törvényei (1911). Ford. Kmoskó Mihály. Kolozsvár: Az Erdélyi Múzeum-Egyesület Jog- és Társadalomtudományi Szakosztálya. Online: https://epa.oszk.hu/eme/books/b1_234480.pdf

HARARI, Yuval N. (2019): 21 Lessons for the 21st Century. London: Vintage.

HAYEK, Friedrich A. (1960): The Constitution of Liberty. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Online: https://ia600805.us.archive.org/35/items/TheConstitutionOfLiberty/The%20Constitution%20of%20Liberty.pdf

HOBBES, Thomas (2010) [1651]: Leviatán. Ford. Vámosi Pál. Budapest: Kossuth.

KÁKOSY László (2005): Az ókori Egyiptom története és kultúrája. Budapest: Osiris.

LENIN, Vlagyimir Iljics (1973) [1918]: Az állam és a forradalom. Ford. Székffy Gyula. Budapest: Kossuth.

LESSIG, Lawrence (2004): Free Culture. New York: Penguin. Online: https://archive.org/download/free_culture/freeculture.pdf

LOCKE, John (1986) [1689]: Értekezés a polgári kormányzatról. Ford. Endreffy Zoltán. Budapest: Gondolat.

MILL, John Stuart (2020) [1859]: A szabadságról. Ford. Pap Mária. Budapest: Helikon.

PIRENNE, Henri (1983): A középkor gazdaság és társadalomtörténete. Ford. Gyáros Erzsébet. Budapest: Gondolat.

Platón (1989): Állam. Ford. Jánosy István. Budapest: Gondolat.

SAVIGNY, Friedrich (1956): Geschichte des römischen Rechts im Mittelalter. Darmstadt: Hermann Gentner Verlag.

SCHAUER, Frederick (2012): Thinking Like a Lawyer. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

SCULLARD, Howard Hayes (2003): A History of the Roman World 753–146 BC. London: Routledge. Online: https://archive.org/details/historyofromanwo0000scul

United Nations (2015): Transforming our world: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. New York. Online: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/1654217?v=pdf

World Economic Forum and UN Sign Strategic Partnership Framework (2019). Online: https://www.weforum.org/press/2019/06/world-economic-forum-and-un-sign-strategic-partnership-framework/

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.