The Prevalence of External States’ Covert Interests over Overtly Emphasised International Conflict Resolution Agendas Throughout a Decade of Libyan Uncertainty

doi: 10.32565/aarms.2023.3.8


This study offers a comparative perspective on four external states’ behavioural tendencies in contrast to their officially upheld ambitions witnessed throughout the past ten years in Libya. Sound promises on conflict resolution, mitigation and alleged alignment with R2P principles is of course nothing new in the international arena, nor is the fact that the parallel existence of selfish agendas constitute an “innovation”. Nevertheless, the case of failed reconciliation and stabilisation process of Libya despite seemingly massive international support offers a recent sphere for investigating the whole spectrum of underlying opposition among the external parties. What started out as a domestically rooted conflict, soon developed into an increasingly international one. After several attempts at the establishment of a truly unified government, interests have never got sufficiently close to each other. What this article sets out to expand on is a fundamentally balance of threats motivated geostrategic opposition, which was only seemingly centred around local key figures like Haftar, Sarraj or even influential tribal leaders. Numerous foreign stakeholders were acting against the very declarations and statements they themselves called their fellows to comply with via means of proxy actions and in hopes of capitalising on the advantages stemming from the status quo. This work discusses the means these states acted counter-productively against the Libyan conflict resolution.


Libya proxy war balance of threat Russia Turkey France Italy

How to Cite

Kása, B. (2023) “The Prevalence of External States’ Covert Interests over Overtly Emphasised International Conflict Resolution Agendas Throughout a Decade of Libyan Uncertainty”, AARMS – Academic and Applied Research in Military and Public Management Science. Budapest, 22(3), pp. 125–135. doi: 10.32565/aarms.2023.3.8.


Ahmed, Omar (2020): Turkey May Have Reclaimed the Leadership of Sunni Islam from Saudi Arabia. Middle East Monitor, 30 July 2020. Online:

Amiel, Sandrine (2019): French Fighter Jets Bomb Chadian Rebels in Support of Deby’s Regime. Euronews, 07 February 2019. Online:

Butler, Daren – Gumrukcu , Tuvan (2019): Turkey Signs Maritime Boundaries Deal with Libya Amid Exploration Row. Reuters, 28 November 2019. Online:

Cammack, Perry – Dunne, Michele: Fueling Middle East Conflicts – or Dousing the Flames. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 23 October 2018. Online:

Chassany, Anne-Sylvaine – Saleh, Heba (2016): Three French Soldiers Killed in Helicopter Crash in Libya. Financial Times, 20 July 2016. Online:

Coskun, Orhan – Gumrukcu , Tuvan (2020): Turkey Ready for Fast Reconstruction in Conflicttorn Libya, Official Says. Reuters, 19 June 2020. Online:

Dal, Emel Parlar (2018a): Assessing Turkey’s Changing Conflict Management Role after the Cold War: Actorness, Approaches and Tools. Third World Quarterly, 39(12), 2291–2314. Online:

Dal, Emel Parlar (2018b): Rising Powers in International Conflict Management: An Introduction. Third World Quarterly, 39(12), 2207–2221. Online:

Dixon, Robyn (2020): Russia’s Ally in Libya Is Battered by Defeats. But Moscow Has Wider Goals to Expand Its Influence. The Washington Post, 06 June 2020. Online:

Dominioni, Irene (2020): Italy Refinances Immigration Agreement with Libya Amid Protests. Forbes, 18 July 2020. Online:

El-Gamaty, Guma (2018): Libya Conflict: Is France an Honest Broker? Middle East Eye, 29 May 2018. Online:

El Wardany, Salma (2019): Total Gets Libya’s Approval to Acquire Marathon Oil’s Assets. World Oil, 11 December 2019. Online:

Gall, Carlotta (2020): Turkey, Flexing Its Muscles, Will Send Troops to Libya. The New York Times, 02 January 2020. Online:

Goodman, Peter S. (2019): Turkey’s Long, Painful Economic Crisis Grinds On. The New York Times, 08 July 2019. Online:

Grand, Camille (2015): The French Experience: Sarkozy’s War? In Mue ller , Karl P. (ed.): Precision and Purpose. Airpower in the Libyan Civil War. Santa Monica: RAND Corporation. 183–204.

Harkai, István (2017): Líbia – a beavatkozás dilemmái egy bukott államban [Libya – The Dilemmas of Intervention in a Failed State]. In Marsai, Viktor – Vogel, Dávid (eds.): Közel Afrikához [Close to Africa]. Budapest: Dialóg Campus. 123–137.

Irish, John – Emmott, Robin (2020): France–Turkey Tensions Mount after NATO Naval Incident. Reuters, 07 July 2020. Online:

Jarry, Emmanuel (2018): France’s Sarkozy Told He Suspected of Taking Gaddafi Election Money. Reuters, 21 March 2018. Online:

Lefèvre, Raphaël (2014): Commentary on Current Events. The Journal of North African Studies, 19(2), 268–273. Online:

Lu, Lingyu – Thies, Cameron G. (2013): War, Rivalry, and State Building in the Middle East. Political Research Quarterly, 66(2), 239–253. Online:; DOI:

McDonald, Matt (2008): Securitization and the Construction of Security. European Journal of International Relations, 14(4), 563–587. Online:

Magdy, Samy (2020): US: Turkey-sent Syrian Fighters Generate Backlash in Libya. The Washington Post, 02 September 2020. Online:

Momtaz, Rym (2020): Macron Criticizes Turkey but Raises Prospect of Dialogue. Politico, 10 September 2020. Online:

Naar, Ismaeel (2020): Turkish Intelligence Agents, Foreign Fighters Arrive in Libya: Sources. Al Arabiya, 06 January 2020. Online:

Peel, Michael – England, Andrew – Mallet, Victor – Pitel, Laura (2020): French Spat with Turkey over Libya Lays Bare European Divisions. Financial Times, 05 July 2020. Online:

Pitel, Laura – Sheppard , David (2020): Turkey Fuels Regional Power Game over Mediterranean Gas Reserves. Financial Times, 18 July 2020. Online:

Pusztai, Wolfgang (2017): The Haftar–Russia Link and the Military Plan of the LNA. ISPI, 02 February 2017. Online:

Ramani, Samuel (2020): Russia’s strategy in Libya. Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), 07 April 2020. Online:

Reynolds, James (2018): Marco Minniti: The Man Who Cut the Migrant Flow to Italy. BBC, 20 September 2018. Online:

Saleh, Heba – Pitel, Laura – Foy, Henry (2020): Putin and Erdogan Call for Ceasefire in Warravaged Libya. Financial Times, 08 January 2020. Online:

Sertin, Carla (2020): ENI and Libya NOC’s Joint Venture Is Losing $9.4 mn Per Day. Oil and Gas Middle East, 02 February 2020. Online:

Shevchenko, Vitaly (2014): Little Green Men or Russian Invaders? BBC, 11 March 2014. Online:

Sørli, E. Mirjam – Gleditsch, Nils P. – Strand, Håvard (2005): Why Is There so Much Conflict in the Middle East? The Journal of Conflict Resolution, 49(1), 141–165. Online:

Taylor , Paul (2019): France’s Double Game in Libya. Politico, 17 April 2019. Online:

Turak, Natasha (2020): Russian Mercenaries, a CIA-linked General and Lots of Oil: Explaining Libya’s War. CNBC, 29 January 2020. Online:

Wezeman, Pieter D. – Fleura nt, Aude – Kuimo va, Alexandra – Tian, Nan – Wezeman, Siemon T. (2018): Trends in International Arms Transfers. SIPRI Fact Sheet, March 2018. Online:


Download data is not yet available.